Independent perspective.
A slightly curious mind.
SearchAbout us
National

Wrongful jail time explained: does India have a law to compensate you?

The Supreme Court gave Devilal Gond ₹30 lakh but said India has no law on compensating wrongful jail time. Here is how claims work today and what could change.

The blue and yellow entrance gate of Vadodara Central Jail with a Gujarati signboard, trees and an empty road in front.
Photograph. · Archival photograph: the entrance of Vadodara Central Jail, Gujarat, May 2019. A representative image; not the prison where Devilal Gond was held. · Credit: Snehrashmi / Wikimedia Commons · Image source · License: CC BY-SA 4.0 · Changes: Cropped to a 3:2 frame and resized to 1200 × 800 pixels; JPEG recompressed. No other visual changes.

On 16 November, the Supreme Court raised Devilal Gond’s compensation to ₹30 lakh for the seven-plus years he spent in jail after being acquitted of murder, and pointed out that India has no law on compensating people held wrongfully. So what happens to someone in his position? The answers below draw on the judgment, the Law Commission’s 2018 report and the reporting around the case.

Is there a law that gives you compensation for wrongful jail time? No. The Supreme Court noted that India has no legislative mechanism laying down the principles or parameters for compensating people who suffer wrongful incarceration, LiveLaw reported. Courts have so far granted relief in individual cases, without making it readily accessible to everyone in a similar position, Hindustan Times reported.

Then how did Gond get money? Through the courts. The Supreme Court and the High Courts can award monetary compensation under Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution, the provisions for writ petitions, when a violation of a fundamental right is established. The bench described this as a public-law remedy founded on strict liability. Taking this route does not stop a person from also filing a civil suit for damages or seeking criminal action against the officials responsible, Hindustan Times reported.

Is the amount fixed? No, it varies case by case. The Chhattisgarh High Court gave Gond ₹2 lakh after he had asked for ₹50 lakh. The Supreme Court raised it to ₹30 lakh, saying compensation cannot be symbolic and must be enough to help the victim rebuild his life and regain financial independence. In September 2025, in the Sohan Singh alias Bablu case, the Supreme Court had ordered Madhya Pradesh to pay ₹25 lakh to a man who stayed in jail for four years and seven months after completing his sentence, LiveLaw reported.

What did the Law Commission suggest? In its 277th report, of August 2018, on wrongful prosecution, the Commission recommended a specific law that would give victims a statutory right to compensation. Claims would go to special courts following summary procedures, with the claimant needing to prove their case only on a “balance of probabilities”. Compensation would include money as well as help such as counselling, mental health services and skills training, plus a provision removing disqualifications that follow a prosecution or conviction. The Commission also drafted a Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 2018.

Why did the Commission want a law? It said the injustice caused to innocent people “needs to be redressed within the framework of rights and not ex gratia by the State”, and that victims need a transparent, uniform and timely remedy. It also noted that the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights requires compensation “according to law” for proven miscarriages of justice, and that India had made a reservation saying its legal system did not recognise a right to compensation for unlawful arrest and detention. Courts later recognised compensation as a remedy under public law, the report said.

What did the court ask for beyond Gond’s case? It asked all High Courts to consider directions like those the Madhya Pradesh High Court issued after the Sohan Singh ruling. Those include prompt communication of acquittal and release orders to jail authorities, compliance reports from trial courts and legal services authorities, and periodic inspections of prisons to find people still held beyond their lawful term. The court also pointed to Madhya Pradesh’s Online Criminal Justice Ecosystem, which shares data and court orders between police, courts, prisons and other agencies, and asked for a copy of the judgment to go to the Registrar Generals of all High Courts, LiveLaw reported.

What happens next? Chhattisgarh has four weeks to pay Gond. For others in his position, the route stays the same until a law is passed: a writ petition and a court’s decision on the amount. The Supreme Court stressed the need for a legislative mechanism, LiveLaw reported, but whether Parliament takes up the Law Commission’s draft is yet to be seen.

More to read

Behind the story

Read the sources and explore the context for yourself.

  1. The Indian Idiot: Acquitted of murder in 2018, Devilal Gond stayed in jail 7 more years; SC awards ₹30 lakh (17 Nov 2026)theindianidiot.com
  2. LiveLaw: Supreme Court Awards Rs. 30 Lakhs To Man Kept In Jail For 7 Years Despite Acquittal, Recommends Law To Compensate Illegal Custody (16 Nov 2026)livelaw.in
  3. Hindustan Times: Supreme Court orders ₹30L compensation for man held in jail 7 years after acquittal (16 Nov 2026)hindustantimes.com
  4. Supreme Court of India: Devilal Gond v. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors., judgment of 16 November 2026api.sci.gov.in
  5. LiveLaw: Supreme Court Orders Rs 25 Lakhs Compensation To Convict Who Spent Additional 4.7 Years In Jail After Serving Sentencelivelaw.in
  6. Law Commission of India, Report No. 277: Wrongful Prosecution (Miscarriage of Justice): Legal Remedies, Recommendations (August 2018)advocatekhoj.com
  7. Law Commission of India, Report No. 277: Wrongful Prosecution (Miscarriage of Justice): Legal Remedies, Conclusion and international obligationsadvocatekhoj.com
More on Wrongful imprisonmentMore in NationalOur corrections policy