Why is this being asked now? The BMC began felling trees at Versova’s Nana Nani Park on 18 November for the Coastal Road North interchange. Of the trees affected, it has approved the cutting of 184 and the transplantation of another 164 to Seven Bungalows in Versova, Hindustan Times reported. Residents have asked the civic body to explore better transplantation technology before it removes mature trees, and the BMC says transplantation is part of the approved plan.
What does transplanting a tree involve? A mature tree is uprooted with as much of its root ball as possible and replanted elsewhere. Dilip Shenai, an ecologist and horticulturist who has consulted for the Maharashtra government on transplantation projects, told The Indian Express that after uprooting, a tree is treated with growth hormones and fungicides, and usually takes about ten days to recover from the shock. It should be replanted close to its original spot, he said, so that soil and air conditions do not change much.
How many transplanted trees survive in Mumbai? Not many, going by the BMC’s own figures. In a March 2024 reply under the Right to Information Act to The Indian Express, the BMC said it transplanted 21,916 mature trees between 2018 and 2023, and fewer than 21% survived. The Indian Express reported in October 2025 that the Supreme Court had also observed that only 50% of the 20,460 trees planted as compensatory afforestation for the Mumbai Metro project had survived.
Why do so many die? Shenai attributes the poor survival rate to haphazard, unscientific transplantation. He said most trees transplanted by the authorities are hardwood species such as mango, teak and jamun, which adapt slowly to a new site, unlike softwood trees such as gulmohar, banyan and babul. “In Mumbai, trees are transplanted within two days, with most of the trees being transplanted in a spot which is far away from the original site,” he told The Indian Express, adding that transplanted trees also need regular watering for about a month, which is often not done.
What do civic officials say? An official told The Indian Express in 2025 that the survival rate is not particularly alarming given Mumbai’s humid coastal climate and high pollution. The official said that, for a project that needs 100 trees cleared, the aim is to cut 60 and try to transplant the rest rather than cut all 100, so that those trees get “a new lease of life”.
What are residents asking for? Dhaval Shah of the Lokhandwala Oshiwara Citizens’ Association told Hindustan Times that more funds should be allocated to bring in modern tree-transplantation technologies from abroad “so that more trees can be saved instead of being cut”. The Nana Nani Park trees set for transplantation are part of the same approved plan. The BMC has not published survival data for this particular batch, and none of the figures above relate to it directly.
More to read
Behind the story
Read the sources and explore the context for yourself.
- The Indian Express: Why SC pulled up Maharashtra govt on afforestation, with low survival of new trees (28 Oct 2025)indianexpress.com
- Hindustan Times: BMC starts axing 184 trees at Versova’s Nana Nani Park for Coastal Road (19 Nov 2026)hindustantimes.com
- Outlook India: 184 Trees, 3,200 Objections: The Dispute Over Mumbai’s Nana Nani Park (19 Nov 2026)outlookindia.com






