Delhi Police have told the Supreme Court that social media reel-makers cannot automatically claim the protection given to journalists while covering protests, and that whether they can be treated as journalists is “yet to be determined”. The police said this in an affidavit responding to petitions by journalists’ bodies over the Jantar Mantar protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar last month, The Indian Express and The Tribune reported.
The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, the Free Speech Collective, the Delhi Union of Journalists and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists. They allege that Delhi Police manhandled, harassed and detained journalists covering the protests. On 11 October, the Supreme Court issued notice on the petitions and directed that lawyers, journalists and other professionals should not be hindered in carrying out their duties “in any manner whatsoever”, The Indian Express reported.
In its affidavit, filed by Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar, the police said journalists “constitute a distinct category” from content creators who use cameras and microphones to make reels for commercial gain. It said the court’s direction “protects journalists in the discharge of their professional duties and does not, and was not intended to, exempt the so-called reel-makers and social media influencers or unruly elements” from the general law or the lawful directions of police at a prohibited assembly.
“While there can be no objection to such activities, the question as to whether such reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined,” the police said. They told the court that “the predominant intent behind the activity may be the decisive factor” in deciding who is a journalist and who is a content creator, The Indian Express and Bar & Bench reported.
The police also said some protesters carrying cameras and microphones falsely identified themselves as journalists, which made it hard to tell reporters from reel-makers in the crowd. The affidavit accepted that the freedom to gather and publish news extends to freelancers, citizens and people reporting on YouTube or other digital platforms, and that this cannot be denied only because someone lacks Press Information Bureau accreditation or an employer-issued press card, Bar & Bench reported.
Delhi Police denied that they deliberately obstructed journalists. “At no point was there any deliberate or concerted action on the part of the Delhi Police to obstruct, restrict or interfere with journalists who were lawfully discharging their professional duties,” the affidavit said. It said that any confusion was inadvertent, caused by mistaken identity or crowd-control measures, and that people detained by mistake were released once their identity was verified, The Indian Express reported.
The police responded to specific allegations as well. They said no material or article was seized from any journalist, and that The Caravan’s Ryan Thomas, who had alleged he was assaulted and detained on 11 October, was “merely removed from the site” under the police’s statutory powers during crowd control, Bar & Bench reported. The police also said Shyam Meera Singh, by his own account, was shouting slogans as part of what they called an illegal protest, which “a journalist would never indulge in”. The petitioners’ allegations have not been tested by the court.
Bar & Bench reported that the protests were those of the Cockroach Janata Party, which called for Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation over alleged irregularities in the special intensive revision of electoral rolls. The petitions are before the Supreme Court.
More to read
Behind the story
Read the sources and explore the context for yourself.
- The Indian Express: ‘Reel makers’ are not journalists, Delhi Police tell Supreme Court (18 Nov 2026)indianexpress.com
- Bar & Bench: Reel-makers can’t claim benefit of Supreme Court order protecting journalists during protests, Delhi Police (18 Nov 2026)barandbench.com
- The Tribune: ‘Reel-makers’ cannot claim journalistic protections, Delhi Police tell Supreme Court (18 Nov 2026)tribuneindia.com






