Idiot Experiences

One place for Indian Movie Reviews

  • Home
  • Just Bollywood
    Just BollywoodShow More
    Ae Watan Mere Watan: Karan Johar are you fr?!
    Bade Miyan Chote Miyan: What A Snoozefest Bruh
    Crew: Average Watch Due To The Weak Writing?
    Dange, just Another Toxic Alpha Male Ego Showdown With All Style But No Substance
    Murder Mubarak Ya Tumhein Boredom Mubarak?
  • OTT Platform
    • Hotstar
    • Netflix
    • Jio Cinema
    • Prime Video
    • Apple TV+
    • SonyLIV
    • ZEE5
    • Others
  • Mood
    • Going Through Breakup
    • I feel like crying
    • Laugh With Frens
    • Need Thrills
    • Mindfuck me
    • Popcorn Dumb Fun
    • Scare me
    • Wholesome Dikhao
  • Movies
    • Action
    • bollywood
    • Animated
    • Horror
    • Comedy
    • Sci-Fi
    • Thriller
    • Superhero
  • TV Shows
    • Drama
    • Fantasy Drama
    • Indian shows
    • Rom-Coms
    • Sitcoms
  • Pop News
    Pop NewsShow More
Reading: Napoleon is an Absolute Feast for the Eyes but with the Feels Missing
Share
Aa
Aa

Idiot Experiences

One place for Indian Movie Reviews

  • OTT Platform
  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Listicles
Search
  • Home
  • OTT Platform
  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Mood
  • Listicles
Follow US
Apple TV+

Napoleon is an Absolute Feast for the Eyes but with the Feels Missing

While the film is entertaining, it lacks the depth required for a truly immersive historical experience, and leaves you wanting for more.
Abhishek Tiwary
Abhishek Tiwary
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE
  • Ridley Scott attempts to portray Napoleon's extraordinary and controversial life, but ends up painting a one-sided, emotionally unavailable picture
  • Joaquin Phoenix and the stunning frames keep it entertaining, but where's the depth?
  • Wolski's artistic frames are all top-notch, but the the screenplay lacks the emotions for the cinematography to shine
  • "Napoleon" is a fun watch, but if you're looking for a deep dive into history, you might want to bring your own shovel.
Review Overview
6.6

The idea of ‘Ridley Scott + Joaquin Phoenix + Historical Drama’ can make a day of a true cinephile. But who knew that the final picture wasn’t gonna be as exciting as the idea? Ridley Scott’s biopic “Napoleon” captures the enigmatic life of the former French emperor, portrayed with captivating intensity by Joaquin Phoenix. With promises of dazzling frames and stellar performances, “Napoleon” seemed like a cinematic feast. However, beneath the surface glamour, you find yourself frustrated due to missed opportunities in terms of painting a more candid picture of his life, by going deep into the complexity of his character and historical impact.

Contents
PlotPerformancesDirection and WritingScreenplay and Cinematography
Source- YouTube- Napoleon Official Trailer/SonyPicturesEntertainment

Plot

We have Marie-Antoinette’s chilling walk to the gallows, while an ambitious Napoleon is watching her closely, to start things off. ISTG, jo tone set ki thi first scene ne>>> From Napoleon’s early military successes to becoming Emperor, the narrative also explores his rocky romance with Joséphine, played by the fiery Vanessa Kirby. The screenplay is a history book revision that covers significant events, including Napoleon’s exile in Elba and the ever-famous Battle of Waterloo. Par the thing is, you get all of it bass surface level pe. This biopic isn’t big on giving you the nitty-gritty of Napoleon’s rule. It’s more like a highlights reel with a side order of frustration. Where did his harsh policies go? What about the reintroduction of slavery in his rule? Error 404: Not Found.

Source- YouTube- Napoleon Official Trailer/SonyPicturesEntertainment

Performances

When it comes to acting, you can always, ALWAYS count on Joaquin Phoenix. Toh kya hua if he has to work with limited material? He breathes life into Napoleon, showcasing that unlike me who has just two moods, the conqueror had multiple ones. Vanessa Kirby is very impressive as she delivers a compelling portrayal of Joséphine. She’s both fire and ice and agar simp karne se time mile toh choose karlena which of her avatars is better, cuz I can’t. The supporting cast, including Tahar Rahim, Ben Miles, and Rupert Everett, adds the needed silk to the narrative but has hardly anything to contribute to the character’s depth. It’s like they are there just to continue the story.

Source- YouTube- Napoleon Official Trailer/SonyPicturesEntertainment

Direction and Writing

Now, this is where things start to go downhill. Ridley Scott’s direction reveals a visually stunning portrayal of Napoleon’s 30-year journey, no doubt. But the thing is, it feels more like a celebration of his life, and not really a biopic. Like, remember how Oppenheimer mein Oppie wasn’t glorified? Nolan showed us both sides of the coin and that’s why it worked. Agar school mein history dhang se padhi hai toh pata hoga ki Napoleon had fcked up big time, not once, but a lot of times during his reign. We’re missing the administrative reforms, the controversial policies—basically, the stuff that makes history spicy. And presenting military victories as luck? Come on, Ridley, we know Napoleon had some tricks up his hat!

Source- YouTube- Napoleon Official Trailer/SonyPicturesEntertainment

Screenplay and Cinematography

Yaha par bhi things don’t go in favour of the movie. The screenplay runs past Napoleon’s key moments but lacks depth in exploring the motivations behind his actions. Wo exam ke pehle one-shot videos dekhte ho na where the teachers say, “Ab samjhaane ka time nahi hai, yaad rakhlo bass.”? It is kinda sorta the same here. The film touches on the French Revolution, with a low-effort text-based cameo just for the sake of it, but fails to connect the audience emotionally to the character’s journey. But here is the silver lining. EVERY shot in Dariusz Wolski’s cinematography is so beautiful, so elegant, just looking like a wowwww. The gut-wrenching battle sequences and the intimate scenes are visually captivating, but har baar ki tarah yaha bhi the emotional punch is MIA.

Source- YouTube- Napoleon Official Trailer/SonyPicturesEntertainment

All in all, biopic banane ka tareeka thoda kezual hai. I mean, “Napoleon” succeeds in presenting a visually arresting summary of the French military commander’s life, thanks to Joaquin Phoenix’s remarkable performance and Wolski’s artistic frames. However, it paints a one-sided picture, ignoring all the horrible aspects of his life, which disconnected me from the movie. Ridley Scott’s director’s cut, running over four hours, hints at potential depth, but theatres mein bhi toh kuch dikhana tha naaa. A decent one-time watch at max.

Review Overview
6.6
Plot 6 out of 10
Cinematography 9 out of 10
Performances 7 out of 10
Dialogues 6 out of 10
Emotions and Historical Accuracy 5 out of 10
Good Stuff Joaquin Phoenix breathes life into Napoleon's character despite a shallow script You cannot appreciate Dariusz Wolski enough for his beautiful as fck shots in every frame
Bad Stuff Ridley Scott celebrates Napoleon, and in the process, forgets to tell us anything about his controversial reforms and the pain he inflicted in his rule The movie is way too short of emotions- neither you get to know the character's motivations, nor do you feel the terror in its battle scenes
Summary
A bio-pic on Napoleon could have been so so much better. It's entertaining, but not quite the best. One-time watch at best.

You Might Also Like

Godzilla X Kong: A Mediocre Addition To The MonsterVerse?

Patna Shuklla: A Courtroom Drama That Lacks Intensity

Jack Johnson’s Self Reliance: A Fun Watch Despite The Half-Baked Plot

Ae Watan Mere Watan: Karan Johar are you fr?!

Suncoast Fumbles On The Feels

TAGGED: Decent, hollywood, Popular
Abhishek Tiwary September 10, 2024 September 10, 2024
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Reddit Telegram Email
What do you think?
Love0
Happy0
Sad0
Cry0
Angry0
Surprise0
Previous Article Boston Strangler is a Flawed but Entertaining Tale of Gruesome Murders
Next Article Animal: a Celebration of Toxic Masculinity, Even Ranbir Kapoor Cannot Compensate
Action

Godzilla X Kong: A Mediocre Addition To The MonsterVerse?

6.4 out of 10
Drama

Patna Shuklla: A Courtroom Drama That Lacks Intensity

6.8 out of 10
Comedy

Jack Johnson’s Self Reliance: A Fun Watch Despite The Half-Baked Plot

6.4 out of 10
[Ruby_E_Template slug="footer"]
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?